Waking up guides

Alarm types compared, with their weaknesses

Every approach to waking up works for somebody and fails for somebody else, usually for a predictable reason. This is the comparison: what each kind is good at, who it suits, and the specific way it breaks.

Ordinary and multiple alarms

An ordinary alarm works for people who get up anyway, and it is the right choice for them. Its weakness is habituation: a familiar sound becomes a sound the sleeping brain discounts, so the alarm that worked in January is inaudible by March.

Stacking five alarms makes that worse. It trains you to ignore alarms as a category and it fragments the last half hour of sleep, so you arrive at the real wake time having rested less than if you had slept through to it.

Puzzles, maths and scanning

Task alarms try to force the brain online. The question for all of them is whether the task can be completed from the bed. A maths problem can, badly, and then the phone goes back on the pillow. The same for shaking the phone, which is a sleeping hand's favourite exercise.

Scanning a barcode in another room is a different matter, because the requirement is location rather than cleverness. It works on the same principle as a distance alarm: get the body somewhere, and being awake follows.

Vibration and light

A vibrating device under the pillow or the mattress reaches many heavy sleepers that sound does not, and it does it without waking a partner or a neighbour. It is the first thing to try in a shared bedroom.

Sunrise lights work gradually and wake people gently, which is their appeal and their limit: a very deep sleeper will sleep through a slowly brightening room. Light plus sound plus vibration together is stronger than any of the three, and that stacking is usually the real answer for someone who sleeps through everything.

Distance alarms

An alarm that only stops once the phone has been carried a set distance is the strongest version of make-the-first-action-impossible-in-bed, which is why Walk2Wake works that way. It also delivers daylight and movement, the two things that end the morning fog fastest.

Its weaknesses are honest ones: it needs the phone with you and location permission, it is unsuitable where walking out at that hour is unsafe or impossible, and it is deliberately inconvenient. People who need it tend to know who they are.

Checklist

  • Ask of any alarm: can this be ended without standing up?
  • Expect to habituate to any sound within weeks.
  • Use one alarm at the real time instead of five before it.
  • In a shared room, start with vibration.
  • Stack light, vibration and sound for a very deep sleeper.
  • Pick the most inconvenient option you will actually keep using.